FDA’s Revamped Approach to Device Safety Will Significantly Change the 510(k) Process

FDA’s Revamped Approach to Device Safety Will Significantly Change the 510(k) ProcessThe Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has decided to significantly change the way it clears the majority of medical devices for marketing in the U.S. The agency plans to place much less emphasis on allowing comparisons with older medical products.

The federal agency’s reliance on these comparisons has been considered by many as a flawed method for determining the adequacy of medical devices to be sold in the marketplace. It is argued that this flaw has led to the distribution of faulty devices, such as defective bloodstream filters and metal hip implants. Rather than relying on complete studies of these products, the FDA has followed the standard referred to as “substantial equivalence” that involves comparisons with already cleared devices of considerable age.

The FDA modernization plan for evaluating device safety

On November 26, 2018, Commissioner of the FDA, Scott Gottlieb and Device Center Director Jeff Shuren published a statement detailing a modernization plan that intends to revamp the 510(k) premarket evaluation program to significantly improve medical device safety. Currently, the 510(k) pathway depends on a prospective medical device undergoing a comparison with a legally marketed predicate device – this is a similar device already deemed legally marketable. Most medical devices are cleared for the market through this 510(k) process.

Critics have pointed to the low standards required by this current process and alleged patient safety issues that have resulted. According to FDA officials, “Data show that nearly 20 percent of current 510(k)s are clearly based on a predicate that’s more than 10 years old.” They further state that as a result, “some devices may not be continually improving.”

The FDA currently uses the 510(k) process to clear approximately 82 percent of medical devices. This generally does not involve the application of gold standard studies in which the product undergoes a comparison with an active treatment control group or a placebo.

The new guidance planned by the FDA for introduction in early 2019 will be called the Safety and Performance Based Pathway. It will allow particular well-understood types of devices to be evaluated based on objective safety and performance criteria for clearance onto the U.S. market.

Use of more modern predicate devices

As a concerns the current 510(k) pathway, the FDA intends to shift the dependence on more modern predicate devices through the potential sun-setting of older predicates – those more than 10 years old – and make them unavailable for substantial equivalence determinations. Congressional input may be required at some point to assist with this fundamental revamping of the current 510(k) program.

Meanwhile, the FDA, in its effort to encourage voluntary application of newer predicate devices, has expressed its possible intention of calling out predicate devices that are greater than 10 years old. The purpose of phasing out older predicates is to foster the implementation of more modern predicates and encourage sponsors to introduce devices with the most recent improvements.

The FDA’s statement goes on to clarify that the agency’s intention is not to eliminate products with older predicates from market or to claim they are unsafe. The goal of the agency is to simply spur the use of more modern predicates by product developers that give “patients and their doctors a choice among older and newer versions of a type of device” as well as promote competition for the development of devices with technological features that enhance safety device and performance.

If you have suffered an injury due to a medical device, our Chicago product liability and medical malpractice attorneys at Gainsberg Law can fight on your behalf to hold liable those responsible for your injuries. We can vigorously advocate on your behalf for the compensation you deserve. To set up a free case evaluation, call us today at 312.313.1621 or complete our contact form.

 

 

 

Free Case Evaluation

No-Obligation Case Review

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Chicago Injury Attorneys

Our Testimonials

L.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg was an excellent attorney. He explained everything to me and made the process very easy. He was available to answer any questions and provided the help and representation that I needed. I would use Neal again if I had another legal issue. I urge anyone who is looking for a lawyer to call Neal."

L.S., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:24:30+00:00

L.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg was an excellent attorney. He explained everything to me and made the process very easy. He was available to answer any questions and provided the help and representation that I needed. I would use Neal again if I had another legal issue. I urge anyone who is looking for a lawyer to call Neal."

N.S., D.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg was our lawyer in a car accident case. We were both injured in addition to our 16 month old daughter. Even though the other driver ran the red light and we had witnesses of her illegal conduct, her insurance company at first denied our claim and said it was our fault. We hired Neal and he fought the insurance company hard. Without having to go to court, he was able to convince the insurance company that it was their driver’s fault. Neal got a great settlement for us and our child within three months of the accident. We were very happy with Neal, he kept us informed about everything, and eased our stress from the accident. If you want an excellent car accident attorney, you need to hire Neal!"

N.S., D.S., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:33:43+00:00

N.S., D.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg was our lawyer in a car accident case. We were both injured in addition to our 16 month old daughter. Even though the other driver ran the red light and we had witnesses of her illegal conduct, her insurance company at first denied our claim and said it was our fault. We hired Neal and he fought the insurance company hard. Without having to go to court, he was able to convince the insurance company that it was their driver’s fault. Neal got a great settlement for us and our child within three months of the accident. We were very happy with Neal, he kept us informed about everything, and eased our stress from the accident. If you want an excellent car accident attorney, you need to hire Neal!"

J.O., Indiana

"Neal Gainsberg at first represented me in a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy case. He explained everything to me and developed a payment plan that I could afford. Whenever I had any questions, Neal responded quickly to any emails or phone calls. Unfortunately, I lost income during my plan, and Neal recommended that I convert the case to a Chapter 7 case. Despite my worries about my finances, Neal made everything easy for me, converted the case, and made sure that I received a fresh start. Neal was very knowledgeable about bankruptcy law, and I highly recommend him as a bankruptcy lawyer."

J.O., Indiana

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T16:42:07+00:00

J.O., Indiana

"Neal Gainsberg at first represented me in a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy case. He explained everything to me and developed a payment plan that I could afford. Whenever I had any questions, Neal responded quickly to any emails or phone calls. Unfortunately, I lost income during my plan, and Neal recommended that I convert the case to a Chapter 7 case. Despite my worries about my finances, Neal made everything easy for me, converted the case, and made sure that I received a fresh start. Neal was very knowledgeable about bankruptcy law, and I highly recommend him as a bankruptcy lawyer."

K.R., Chicago, IL

"After my former lawyer refused to continue with my auto accident case, Neal Gainsberg took over the case, and he was able to obtain a settlement for the other driver’s policy limits. He was actively involved in my case, returned all my calls, and explained any issue that I had during the case. After I spoke with Neal, he was able to resolve any problems or issues. Neal provided exceptional representation against the insurance company for the other driver. Since Neal settled my case, I have recommended him to my family members and friends. If you have a legal issue, you should call Neal and hire him to be your attorney."

K.R., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:21:53+00:00

K.R., Chicago, IL

"After my former lawyer refused to continue with my auto accident case, Neal Gainsberg took over the case, and he was able to obtain a settlement for the other driver’s policy limits. He was actively involved in my case, returned all my calls, and explained any issue that I had during the case. After I spoke with Neal, he was able to resolve any problems or issues. Neal provided exceptional representation against the insurance company for the other driver. Since Neal settled my case, I have recommended him to my family members and friends. If you have a legal issue, you should call Neal and hire him to be your attorney."

J.T., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg was a great lawyer. He represented me at a small claims trial and obtained a great result. Neal was there for me and answered all my questions even though my case was not that large."

J.T., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:21:23+00:00

J.T., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg was a great lawyer. He represented me at a small claims trial and obtained a great result. Neal was there for me and answered all my questions even though my case was not that large."

M.T.G., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg took my personal injury claim against large store after I fell on water and injured my knee and back. The store employees disputed that anything happened and the manager accused me and my son, who witnessed the fall, of making it up. Neal brought a lawsuit against the store, took several depositions of the store employees, and obtained a great settlement for me and my family. Neal fought hard on my case, and I was very pleased with the results."

M.T.G., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:18:57+00:00

M.T.G., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg took my personal injury claim against large store after I fell on water and injured my knee and back. The store employees disputed that anything happened and the manager accused me and my son, who witnessed the fall, of making it up. Neal brought a lawsuit against the store, took several depositions of the store employees, and obtained a great settlement for me and my family. Neal fought hard on my case, and I was very pleased with the results."

E.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg represented me in my Chapter 13 case. He knew all the details about bankruptcy and my case, explained everything to me in the beginning, made every issue easy to understand, and provided the help I needed during the five years of the plan. As a result of Neal’s legal assistance, I was able to make all my plan payments and get a fresh start. I highly recommend that anyone considering bankruptcy to give Neal a call."

E.S., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:22:30+00:00

E.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg represented me in my Chapter 13 case. He knew all the details about bankruptcy and my case, explained everything to me in the beginning, made every issue easy to understand, and provided the help I needed during the five years of the plan. As a result of Neal’s legal assistance, I was able to make all my plan payments and get a fresh start. I highly recommend that anyone considering bankruptcy to give Neal a call."

R.P., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg is a smart and an aggressive lawyer. He did a great job on my case. He helped me with a money dispute with a former friend and obtained a judgment for me. Neal listened and paid attention to any question I had, answered my calls right away, and was there for me at every point during the case. He knew exactly what to do in court. If you are looking to get compensation, I highly recommend that you hire Neal."

R.P., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:35:21+00:00

R.P., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg is a smart and an aggressive lawyer. He did a great job on my case. He helped me with a money dispute with a former friend and obtained a judgment for me. Neal listened and paid attention to any question I had, answered my calls right away, and was there for me at every point during the case. He knew exactly what to do in court. If you are looking to get compensation, I highly recommend that you hire Neal."

V.S.G. and M.G., Richton Park, IL

"Neal is a great attorney. He helped us with several legal issues, including obtaining a large settlement for us following a car accident. He worked very hard on our case from the start, answered all our phone calls and questions, and kept us continually updated. Since then, we have used Neal for other civil matters. We have known Neal for over 13 years, and call him whenever we have a legal question. We know Neal will be there to help us."

V.S.G. and M.G., Richton Park, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:25:43+00:00

V.S.G. and M.G., Richton Park, IL

"Neal is a great attorney. He helped us with several legal issues, including obtaining a large settlement for us following a car accident. He worked very hard on our case from the start, answered all our phone calls and questions, and kept us continually updated. Since then, we have used Neal for other civil matters. We have known Neal for over 13 years, and call him whenever we have a legal question. We know Neal will be there to help us."

L.G., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg helped me obtain long-term disability benefits. The insurance company denied my claim and cutoff my benefits even though I was set for surgery and there was no way I could work. Neal collected my medical records and letters from my doctors and had my benefits reinstated. I have had no issues with the insurance company once I hired Neal."

L.G., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T19:19:37+00:00

L.G., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg helped me obtain long-term disability benefits. The insurance company denied my claim and cutoff my benefits even though I was set for surgery and there was no way I could work. Neal collected my medical records and letters from my doctors and had my benefits reinstated. I have had no issues with the insurance company once I hired Neal."

M.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg represented me in a personal injury case after a vehicle struck a motorcycle that I was riding on. Neal made sure I understood my rights as an injured party, and that I was receiving the proper medical attention. He did a great job in negotiating a settlement with the insurance company and making sure all my medical bills were paid and that I was compensated for my injuries and loss time at work. I recommend Neal as a lawyer to anyone who unfortunately is injured in an accident."

M.S., Chicago, IL

Gainsberg Law P.C.
5.0
2016-11-21T16:41:13+00:00

M.S., Chicago, IL

"Neal Gainsberg represented me in a personal injury case after a vehicle struck a motorcycle that I was riding on. Neal made sure I understood my rights as an injured party, and that I was receiving the proper medical attention. He did a great job in negotiating a settlement with the insurance company and making sure all my medical bills were paid and that I was compensated for my injuries and loss time at work. I recommend Neal as a lawyer to anyone who unfortunately is injured in an accident."
5
11
Chicago BarIllinois BarYelpAvvoBBB
Text Us312-313-1621